Patterdale vs Border Terrier: Which Breed Is Quieter?

There are many energetic terrier breeds, but if you're looking for an active, fun-loving small dog for outdoor adventures, the Patterdale and the Border Terrier are two breeds worth comparing.

Origins and Background of the Breeds

Patterdale Terrier puppies have been around for over 100 years and are often called Black Fell Terriers. Originating in southern Scotland, northern England, Yorkshire, and the Lake District, they were bred as hardy hunting dogs capable of working difficult terrain. Despite their popularity as family pets today, the breed is not officially recognised by the Kennel Club.

Border Terrier puppies, first developed on the Anglo-Scottish border, originally went by the names Redesdale or Coquetdale Terriers until the late 19th century. Related to breeds like the Dinmont and Patterdale Terriers, they were bred for courage, stamina, and loyalty. With historical roots tracing back to the 18th century, Border Terriers remain a beloved choice for families and active owners.

Physical Appearance and Size

Patterdales are compact and balanced dogs, standing 25 to 40 cm tall and weighing between 7 and 14 kg. They possess a remarkable chest ability to compress, enabling them to squeeze through narrow spaces.

Border Terriers are similarly sized, with males typically 33 to 40 cm tall and weighing 6 to 7 kg. Their sturdy, compact build and otter-like head are distinctive features.

Temperament and Barking Tendencies

Both breeds are energetic and lively, but in general, the Border Terrier is considered the quieter breed. Border Terriers tend not to bark excessively and will alert owners to visitors or unusual activities without being overly vocal. They make excellent watchdogs but are affectionate and relatively calm indoors.

Patterdales are also highly energetic with an independent streak and a strong prey drive. They have been described as lively and sometimes verging on overly intense, often accompanied by a louder bark. These dogs require consistent training and significant exercise to manage their energy levels and noise potential.

Shedding and Grooming

Both breeds are low shedders, losing coat steadily year-round with increased shedding during seasonal coat changes in spring and autumn. Patterdales can have smooth, rough, or broken coats, all with thick undercoats. Border Terriers typically have dense, coarse coats with a close undercoat.

Training and Exercise Requirements

Both terriers are intelligent and trainable but need early socialisation and clear boundaries. Patterdales, due to their independent nature and strong prey drive, benefit from firm yet fair training. Border Terriers are quick learners but may develop bad habits without proper guidance. A minimum of 60 minutes of daily exercise combined with mental stimulation is necessary for both breeds to thrive.

Compatibility with Children and Other Pets

Both breeds suit families with older children and can form strong bonds with cats they are raised with. However, caution is advised around smaller pets due to their hunting instincts.

Health and Lifespan

Patterdale Terriers generally have fewer hereditary health issues, with occasional eye problems such as conjunctivitis. Border Terriers face more hereditary conditions, including hip dysplasia, progressive retinal atrophy, and certain neurological syndromes. Lifespans for both breeds average between 12 and 15 years with proper care and nutrition.

Conclusion: Which is the Quieter Choice?

When comparing the two, the Border Terrier is typically the quieter breed, known for alerting without excessive barking and for being a calm companion indoors. Patterdales are energetic and vocal, requiring experienced owners who can provide adequate exercise and training. Both breeds demand commitment and care but make loyal and courageous companions for the right owners.

If you are considering finding a puppy, always seek reputable breeders that prioritise ethical breeding and animal welfare to ensure healthy, happy puppies.